On Comment Guard - WordPress Comment Spam Prevention Plugin关于评论民警卫队-在W ordPress垃圾评论预防插件
Yesterday I talked about developing a昨天我谈到发展 comment spam prevention plugin垃圾评论预防插件 with zero false positives . 零假阳性 。 I am currently using it on all of our blogs.我目前使用的,它在我们所有的博客。 Today I want to talk briefly about its origin and goals.今天,我想简单地谈一谈关于它的起源和目标。
But first here are the stats from my但首先,这里是从我的统计 Simple Thoughts blog简单的思考博客 : :
1095 spam comments were blocked by Angsuman’s Comment Guard plugin in 23 hours 46 minutes. 1095年垃圾评论阻断Angsuman的评论民警卫队插件在23小时46分钟。 99.094% of the comments you received during this time were spam. 99.094 %的意见,您收到在这段时间分别是垃圾邮件。
Stats for统计资料 Anaconda Theme blog康达主题博客 : :
1982 spam comments were blocked by Angsuman’s Comment Guard plugin in 3 days 10 hours 14 minutes. 1982年垃圾评论阻断Angsuman的评论民警卫队插件在3天10小时14分钟。 99.748% of the comments you received during this time were spam. 99.748 %的意见,您收到在这段时间分别是垃圾邮件。
As you can see it is quite effective.你可以看到,这是相当有效。 After I installed the Comment Guard plugin my Akismet queue is empty.之后,我安装了评论民警卫队插件我的akismet队列是空的。 I haven’t received any spam comments since.我并没有收到任何垃圾邮件的评论以来。 However I have received some valuable comments during this time.不过,我曾收到一些宝贵意见,在这段时间。 I have gained more time to answer to them as I do not have to anymore clean up spam from Moderation queue (used to get around 100 per day from Simple Thoughts blog alone; spams which passed through Akismet queue)我获得了更多时间来回答他们,正如我不须再清理垃圾邮件从审阅队列(用来取得约100每天从简单的思考博客单;垃圾邮件,其中通过akismet队列)
BTW: I did receive a comment in Chinese which was suspiciously small in length and so I suspected it to be spam.的BTW :我没有收到评论在中国这是形迹可疑的小,长度,所以我怀疑它是垃圾邮件。 However on Google translation I realized it is a valid comment asking me when I would release the next version of Anaconda theme.然而, Google翻译我意识到这是一个有效的评论,问我,当我将释放下一版本的康达主题。 I am impressed by how much you can write in little space in Chinese.我留下深刻的印象多少,你也可以撰写在狭小的空间在中国。 See for yourself见自己 here这里 . 。
Comment Guard is a labor of love more than anything else. 评论民警卫队是一项劳动,爱比任何事情都重要。 It is born out of my strong experiences and pain with handling comment spam in several of my blogs.这是诞生于我的经验和强烈的疼痛与处理垃圾评论在几个我的博客。 I respect my readers and will not take them through hoops to post a comment.我尊重我的读者,并不会采取他们通过箍,以张贴评论。 However I could never find a clean way in numerous plugins I used to completely stop robot / program generated comment spam.不过,我可从来没有找到一个清洁的方式在众多插件我用完全停止机器人/程序产生的垃圾评论。
Anti-spam plugins adopt questionable techniques like checking RBL (and other such black hole lists) for identifying spam IP’s.反垃圾邮件插件采取质疑的技术一样,检查乡(和其他此类黑洞名单)确定垃圾邮件的IP的。 This is plain wrong.这是完全错误的。 Many people, for example, connect from countries like India where ISP’s primarily issue dynamic IP’s.很多人,例如连接由国家像印度这样的地方ISP的主要问题,动态IP的。 Spam Karma 2 blocks them from posting comment in many cases because the RBL it uses blocks the whole dynamic IP ranges solely because they are dynamic and sometimes because someone from these IP’s have in the past spammed someone.垃圾邮件的因果报应2块,他们从发布评论,在许多情况下,因为它使用乡大厦的整个动态IP的范围,纯粹是因为他们是动态的,有时是因为有人从这些IP的已在过去的垃圾邮件的人。 This is something people do not have any control.这是一些人没有任何控制。 The usual solutions suggested are contacting the IP to remove these addresses.通常的解决方案建议,是联系的IP ,以删除这些地址。 It is easier said then done.这是说起来容易,然后做了。 In India ISP’s enjoy near-monopoly (like BSNL) and most often they do not care about their customers, let alone do something at their request.在印度ISP的享有几乎垄断(如印度BSNL )和大多数,他们往往不关心他们的客户,更遑论做一些事,在他们的要求。 Nowadays some RBL’s have started charging fees for removal!现在一些乡郊建屋地段的已开始收取费用,搬迁! In essence checking RBL is a bad policy.在本质上检查乡是一个坏的政策。 It is only acceptable if you do not care a bit about your readers and what they have to say.这是唯一可以接受的,如果你不照顾一下您的读者和他们的意见。
Then there are checking for proxies.然后有检查委托书。 Again there are RBL’s which are used to check for open proxies and many of the anti-spam plugin decide to block them.再有乡的这是用来检查开放的代理人和很多的反垃圾邮件插件决定来阻止他们。 This is a draconian policy.这是一个严苛的政策。 In many countries like China or even Iran people are forced to access web through proxy to get access to most content.在许多国家和中国一样,甚至伊朗人民是被迫访问的网站通过代理,以获得大多数内容。 Blocking proxies effectively blocks lots of valuable readers.阻断代理人有效座很多宝贵的读者。
Plugins like SK 2 makes guesses about user behavior based on the author’s observation which in many cases are wrong.插件一样的SK 2 ,使猜测用户行为的基础上,作者的观察,在许多情况下都是错误的。 A case in point.一个典型的例子。 I tried to contact a customer who was having problems.我曾尝试联络客户谁是有问题。 I wasn’t able to connect with him via email as it was getting bounced due to mail server error.我是无法连接到与他通过电子邮件,因为这是获得反弹,由于邮件服务器的错误。 So I tried posting a comment to his blog.因此,我试图张贴评论他的博客。 The comment kept getting rejected , most likely because SK2 determines that comments can only be of certain size and no more!评论不断取得拒绝,最有可能是因为sk2决定的评论,只能对一定规模和没有更多! So I persisted and tried submitting, without success, with smaller and smaller size.因此,我坚持,并试图提交,没有成功,与小尺寸。 After some attempts SK2 determined I was a spammer and informed me that I was reported to Akismet.经过一些尝试sk2确定我是一个垃圾邮件发送者,并告诉我,我是报akismet 。
When you go down and dirty with the code you will find tons of such inane assumptions.当您走和肮脏与代码你会发现吨这种inane的假设。 I can go on whole night about them.我可以去对整个晚上约他们。 The bottomline is I couldn’t trust my blog with SK2 or Bad Behaviour.底线是,我不能信任我的博客与sk2或坏的行为。 Even Akismet has lots of false positive issues. akismet ,甚至有很多假阳性的问题。 However it is better of the three.不过,最好是上述三个。 Even then I was getting over 100 spams in moderation queue for this blog alone.即使在当时我买的超过100个垃圾邮件在审阅队列为此博客单。 I was going way over my bandwidth and people thought what was I doing all day.我去的方式超过我的带宽和人民的思想,什么是我做的所有天。
Out of this frustration Comment Guard was born.出于这种挫折感评论后卫诞生了。 I am very happy to say that so far it has given me 100% success rate .我很高兴地说,到目前为止,它让我有百分之一百的成功率。 I am testing it on all my blogs and will continue to do so for about a month, or till I am confident that I have fully tamed the beast.我测试它的所有我的Blog ,并会继续这样做,约一个月,或到我深信我已完全驯服野兽。 I know that I will be fully happy with this plugin if all it does is stop 100% of spams on my sites only.我知道我将得到充分乐意与此插件,如果所有它是停止100 %的垃圾邮件对我的网站只。 I would however be happy to enroll beta testers after about a week.不过,我很乐意参加Beta测试后,约一个星期。 So if you would like to test it, let me know.因此,如果你想测试它,让我知道。
BTW: If you are a spammer, bring it on baby!的BTW :如果你是一个垃圾邮件发送者, 使其对婴儿!
Filed under提起下 CMS Software CMS软件 , , Comment Guard Plugin评论民警卫队插件 , , Headline News头条新闻 , , Pro Blogging赞成Blogging , , Spam Watch垃圾邮件观赏 , , Technology技术 , , Web网页 , , Web Hosting虚拟主机 , , Web Services Web服务 , , WordPress在WordPress | |
| |
RSS 2.0 2.0 | |
Trackback Trackback跟踪 this Article |此文章|
Email this Article电子邮件此文章
You may also like to read您也可以想读 |





January 18th, 2007 at 9:38 pm 2007年1月18日在下午9点38分
Are you sure it was SK2 blocking you.您确定这是sk2阻止你。 I’ve faced no problem with SK2 and RBL.我已经面临没有问题, sk2和乡。 However, I have faced a problem with Bad Behavior and RBL lists.不过,我所面临的问题与不良行为和乡名单。
BSNL is not the only one. BSNL公司是不是只有一个。 All the major and minor ISPs have blacklisted IPs.所有主要和次要互联网服务供应商列入黑名单的IP 。
Btw, will you plugin be free or paid?的BTW ,你会插件是免费或支付?
January 18th, 2007 at 10:16 pm 2007年1月18日在下午10时16分
Let me know if and when you need testers.让我知道,如果和当您需要测试。
January 18th, 2007 at 10:39 pm 2007年1月18日在下午10时39分
> Are you sure it was SK2 blocking you >您确定这是sk2阻止你
Yes.是。 It was on connectedinternet.co.uk server as far as I can remember.这是对connectedinternet.co.uk服务器作为据我记忆所及。 SK 2 uses RBL. SK队2使用乡。
Some RBL’s actually blacklist all dynamic IP’s!一些乡的黑名单,其实所有的动态IP的!
RBL’s have truly become a draconian and authoritarian system as some had predicted in their early days.乡郊建屋地段的已真正成为一个恶法和威权体制的一些曾预测,在他们的早年。
> Btw, will you plugin be free or paid? >的BTW ,你会插件是免费或支付?
I haven’t decided yet.我尚未决定。 I will decide it based on the amount of effort we put in. Most of my plugins are free.我会决定它的基础上,数额的努力,我们提出英寸我大部分的插件都是免费的。 At this stage of development I can release it for free, however with source code obscured to hinder spammers.在这个发展阶段,我可以释放它为免费,自由,但与源代码遮蔽,阻碍垃圾邮件发送者。 However if I decide to include more capabilities to provide more comprehensive coverage from live human spammers, then I may charge a nominal fee.但是如果我决定以包括更多的能力,以提供更全面的覆盖范围从人类的生活垃圾邮件发送者的话,我可能会收取象征式的费用。
January 18th, 2007 at 10:48 pm 2007年1月18日在下午10时48分
Thanks BigDog for the offer to beta test.感谢bigdog为提供测试。 I have added you to the list.我补充说:你到清单中。
January 19th, 2007 at 12:07 am 2007年1月19日在上午12时07分
I got this twice:我得到这两次:
while commenting.而评论。
Regarding Connected Internet, when did you face this problem.关于连接互联网,当你面对这个问题。 He was earlier running Akismet and even I landed in the bin, until I made it switch over to SK2.他是较早运行akismet和连我自己降落在该斌,直到我曾切换到sk2 。
The only problem I faced with SK2 so far was too many comments in too short a while.唯一的问题i面对sk2至今太多的评论太短了一段时间。 But, I guess the RBL must have kicked in for you.不过,我猜想乡必须在踢你。
Anyway, since you’re plugin works even before that it is really good.无论如何,由于您插件工程,甚至之前,实在是好。
Look forward to it期待着它
January 19th, 2007 at 1:00 am 2007年1月19日在上午01点
My blog is being hammered by spam comments of late too (though not as much as yours ;)).我的博客正在敲定由垃圾邮件的评论晚太(虽然不是高达你; ) ) 。 I currently use Akismet but it has let in a few comments get past which thankfully were caught in the moderation queue.我现在使用akismet ,但它已经让在几点意见得到过去幸好被发现,在温和的队列中。
I would be glad to try out your plugin and beta test it if you need me to as well我会高兴地尝试了你的插件和测试,它如果您需要,我以及
Ps.保安局常任秘书长。 I tried to comment once before this but I got the same error msg as Ajay above.我试图评论,一旦在此之前,但我得到了相同的错误讯息,作为ajay以上。
January 19th, 2007 at 8:36 am 2007年1月19日在上午8时36分
Thanks Ajay & AJ.感谢ajay &的AJ 。 We found the bug too (the message Ajay and you mentioned) and we are working on it.我们发现错误太(信息ajay和你所提到的)和我们的工作。
Thanks AJ for volunteering.感谢的AJ志愿。 I have added you to our list of beta testers.我补充说:你到我们的清单的Beta测试。
January 19th, 2007 at 9:11 am 2007年1月19日在上午09时11分
Latest stats from this blog:最新的统计从这个博客:
January 21st, 2007 at 12:14 am 2007年1月21日在上午12时14分
That bug was related to your plugin?该错误是与您的插件? It’s still not resolved… Faced it while writing this comment.它的仍然没有得到解决…面对它,而写这本发表评论。
January 21st, 2007 at 1:52 am 2007年1月21日在上午01时52分
Found the reason, a simple one really.发现的原因,一个简单的一真的。
We will very soon update the site with the fix.我们会很快更新的网站与该修补程序。 In the meantime you can just refresh the page.在此期间,您可以只刷新页面。
January 21st, 2007 at 1:57 am 2007年1月21日在上午01时57分
We are still seeing 100% accuracy.我们看到的仍然是100 %的准确性。
In Comment Guard you too will be able to plug-in your modules.在评论民警卫队,你也将能够插件在您的模块。
January 23rd, 2007 at 6:52 pm 2007年1月23日在下午6时52分
Can you discuss the theory/algorithm behind your plugin?你是否可以讨论的理论/算法背后,您的插件?
January 23rd, 2007 at 7:59 pm 2007年1月23日在下午7点59分
Frankly I want to; but I don’t think it will be prudent at this time.坦白说,我想,但我不认为这将是审慎的在这个时候。 I don’t want to give any information to spammers about a plugin that is so far giving me 100% protection.我不想提供任何资料,以垃圾邮件发送者约1插件这是到目前为止,给我百分之一百的保障。
The funny thing was that Akismet caught two comments as spam during this time, comments which passed through my plugin.有趣的是, akismet陷入两点意见为垃圾邮件在这段时间内,评论,其中通过我的插件。 Both of the comments were legit.这两种意见分别为合法。 You would be surprised to know your comment was one of them你会惊讶地知道您的意见是,其中一人
January 23rd, 2007 at 8:00 pm 2007年1月23日在下午八时
Comment Guard says:评论警卫说:
It looks like comment spammers are getting afraid of spamming me these days它看起来像评论垃圾邮件发送者越来越害怕滥发我这些天
January 24th, 2007 at 1:19 pm 2007年1月24日在下午1时19分
Yes, I am surprised.是的,我觉得很奇怪。 I’m an Akismet user myself.我是一个akismet用户自己。 AFAIK I’ve never been blocked by them before. afaik我从来没有被封锁,他们之前。
Are you planning to make this plugin available at some point?你的规划,使此插件可在一些点?
January 24th, 2007 at 2:00 pm 2007年1月24日下午2:00
Yes, we have started working on it again, adding some features and fixing one bug.是的,我们已开始工作,它再次,加入一些功能和操纵一个错误。 I am thinking of a beta release next week.我想到的Beta版本下周。
BTW: You are not the only one.的BTW :你是不是只有一个。 Even James, a frequent commentator on this blog, was also甚至詹姆斯,经常评论员:此博客,也 caught by Akismet受akismet . 。 These days I am seeing the true performance of Akismet and I am not impressed with its high rate of false positives.这些天来我看到的真实业绩的akismet ,我不留下深刻的印象,其高企的假阳性。
January 24th, 2007 at 6:35 pm 2007年1月24日在下午6时35分
I’d be happy to beta test it for you.我很乐意测试,它给你。
February 2nd, 2007 at 4:48 am 2007年2月2日在上午04时48分
Ajay, ajay ,
This blog has been updated with the latest version and the problem you reported has been solved.此博客已更新与最新版本和您所报告的问题已经解决。
All,全部,
We will be sending the copies for beta testers soon.我们将派遣副本为测试者尽快。
Best,最好的,
Angsuman由Angsuman
March 3rd, 2008 at 9:11 pm 2008年3月3日在下午9点11分
I am very happy to say that我很高兴地说, Comment Guard Pro评论民警卫队亲 has finally been released.终于被释放。 It is feature rich and extremely accurate.这是功能丰富和非常准确。 Please check it out!请检查出来!