Error of Spam Protection by Restricting Comments on Old Posts錯誤的垃圾郵件保護限制的意見,對舊帖子
There is a widespread assumption by many bloggers that comments on old posts are mostly spam.有一種普遍的假設是由許多Blogger的評論對舊帖子,大多是垃圾郵件。 There are several WordPress plugins to prevent commenting on old posts, even posts as recent as one month old like, for example, Akismet.有幾個wordpress插件,以防止在評論歲的職位,即使職位最近的作為一個月歲,例如, akismet 。 This is plain wrong and can result in losing many valuable comments .這是完全錯誤的,可能導致失去很多寶貴的意見 。 Such practices should be discouraged by bloggers.這種做法,應勸阻由博客。 Let me explain why.讓我解釋一下為什麼。
Some blogs, like this blog for example, publish guides and tips which are not bound by time and can be valid even after years.一些博客,喜歡這個博客,例如,發布指導和提示,這是不受時間和可以有效的,甚至經過多年。 Several of my guides and articles, even from 2004, are still referenced and widely commented upon.幾個我的指南和文章,甚至從2004年起,仍參照,並廣泛評論。 Preventing comments on such posts or assuming they are spam is incorrect and will definitely result in rejecting many genuine and often informative comments.防止對此類職位,或假設他們是垃圾郵件是不正確,一定會拒絕,結果在很多真正的,而且往往內容翔實的意見。
Initially blogs were started on the premise of maintaining a web log or journal.最初的博客開始對的前提下維持一個Web日誌或雜誌。 Hence blog by nature is chronological.因此,博客的性質是時間順序。 However in practice while blogs are used for time bound articles like what you did today morning or late in the night (sorry, I am not interested), they are often used for publishing many timeless articles too like, for example, my blog or但在實踐中,而Blog是用於時限的文章一樣,什麼你今天早上或深夜(對不起,我不感興趣) ,他們常常被用於出版的許多永恆的文章太多,例如,我的博客或 Steve Pavlina’s blog史蒂夫pavlina的博客 or或 ProBlogger ,解決 . 。
Spam prevention shouldn’t be hard.垃圾郵件的預防應該並不難。 Too much well-meaning but basically flawed strategies have been used over the years for stopping comment spam and preventing comments on old posts add to that list.太多的本意良好,但基本上是有缺陷的戰略,已用於多年來,為阻止垃圾評論和預防的評論對舊帖子添加到這一名單。
Filed under提起下 Comment Guard Plugin評論民警衛隊插件 , , Headline News頭條新聞 , , Pro Blogging贊成Blogging , , Web網頁 , , Web 2.0 Web 2.0的 , , WordPress在WordPress , , WordPress Plugin wordpress插件 | |
| |
RSS 2.0 2.0 | |
Trackback Trackback跟踪 this Article |此文章|
Email this Article電子郵件此文章
You may also like to read您也可以想讀 |





December 7th, 2007 at 12:18 pm 2007年12月7日在下午12時18分
Akismet does not prevent comments from being added to old posts. akismet並不妨礙評論被添加到舊帖子。 It does have an option which deletes spam comments added to posts over a month old, rather than hold them for review, which is quite nice for low-to-mid-traffic blogs as those spam comments can pile up rather quickly.它確實有一個選項,其中刪除垃圾郵件的評論加入職位超過一個月歲,而非舉行以供審查,這是相當好的,為低到中交通博客作為那些垃圾郵件的評論可以堆積較快。
December 7th, 2007 at 2:53 pm 2007年12月7日在下午2時53分
I agree with you.我同意你的。 While I’ve noticed that older posts tend to be targeted by comment spammers, I’ve also received some good comments on these older posts as well.雖然我已經注意到,老年人的職位往往是針對垃圾郵件發送者的評論,我也收到了一些很好的意見,這些年紀較大的職位,以及。
Using a time restricted commenting plugin also dulls the value Related Posts and other similar plugins as well.使用時間限制在評論插件也dulls價值的相關文章和其他類似的插件,以及。
December 8th, 2007 at 7:31 am 2007年12月8日在上午07時31分
James,詹姆斯,
Akismet (controlled by an option)dies when a reader tries to comment on a post older than 1 month. akismet (控制的一個選項)去世時,一位讀者嘗試發表評論後的老年人超過1個月。 It does it while submitting the comment.它的確能做到,而提交評論。
In essence if this option is checked, Akismet assumes that the comment is a spam, guilty before any fair trial.在本質上,如果這個選項被勾選, akismet假設條件是,該評論是垃圾郵件,有罪以前,任何公平的審訊。 Akismet is just an example. akismet只是一個例子。 There are other plugins too which does this by making the post non-commentable.還有其他插件太其中,這是否使郵政非commentable 。
Frank you have raised a very valid point.坦率你提出了一個非常有效的點。 Many of us show related posts which may be from the past.我們很多人顯示相關的職位,可能會從過去的。 When a user browses to such posts he will find that they cannot be comented upon.當用戶瀏覽到這些職位,他將發現他們不能comented後。
December 9th, 2007 at 1:53 am 2007年12月9日在上午01時53分
The option which you’re referring to is “Automatically discard spam comments on posts older than a month.” With this option enabled, Akismet will only automatically delete a comment left on an old post if it has been judged as spam by Akismet.選項您指的是“自動丟棄垃圾郵件的評論對職位的老年人超過一個月。 ”這個選項啟用, akismet ,只會自動刪除評論留在舊的文章,如果它已判斷為垃圾郵件akismet 。 Legitimate comments make it through without a problem.合法的意見,使通過沒有問題。
December 12th, 2007 at 12:42 pm 2007年12月12日在下午12時42分
You are right, Akismet first checks for its spamminess before.你說得對, akismet會先檢查其spamminess前。 However it is well known that Akismet returns不過,這是人所共知的akismet回報 lots地段 of …的 false虛假 positives陽性 . 。 In fact your comment above was marked as spam by Akismet!事實上,您的評論以上是標示為垃圾郵件所akismet !
While Akismet spam queue was intended for checking for such false positives, in reality with several thousands in the spam queue, it is almost impossible to check them, so effectively when Akismet marks something as a spam it becomes a spam and in case of comments on older posts they are deleted.而akismet垃圾郵件隊列的用意是為檢查等假陽性,在現實與數千名在垃圾郵件隊列,它幾乎是不可能的檢查,因此,有效地時, akismet馬克的東西作為一個垃圾郵件成為垃圾郵件和在案件的評論舊帖子,他們都將被刪除。 However Akismet is just one of the many plugins which target comments on older posts.不過akismet只是其中之一許多插件對象的意見,對老年人的職位。 The focus of this article isn’t Akismet, which was merely mentioned en passant, but the concept of rejecting (in one form or other) or even discriminating against comments on older posts.本文的重點不是akismet ,這僅僅是提到英文passant ,但概念,拒絕(以某種形式或其他) ,甚至是歧視的評論對老年人的職位。
I contend that we cannot determine the spamminess of a comment looking merely at how old the post it has commented on.我認為我們無法確定spamminess的評論看,只是在如何歲後有評論。