Close to 10, 000 Comments; Mystery Gift for 10, 000th Commenter!September 23rd, 2008 This blog is actively protected by Comment Guard Pro, WordPress Comment Spam protection plugin for pro-bloggers and semi-pro bloggers. We don't allow any spam, even apparently innocuous ones in this blog.
Comment SpamFebruary 6th, 2004 After some deliberation, and seeing others, I decided to leave the commenting section on my blog un-moderated. Today I was mildly surprised to find almost all my posts had a comment to it.
Blog Comments Problem SolvedFebruary 22nd, 2006 Simple Thoughts Blog had a sporadic but consistent comment problem. On submitting comments a blank page was occasionally returned instead of the original page with the comment added.
Comment Guard Pro in Final Stages of DevelopmentNovember 4th, 2007 Comment Guard Pro is finally turning out to be the uber anti-comment spam protection plugin I dreamt of; everything you would ever want in a comment spam protection plugin and more, much more. The plugin itself is composed of several modules, each of which can be individually enabled / disabled, tweaked and configured all from the user interface.
Experimental Comment Spam Prevention System for WordPress BlogsJanuary 17th, 2007 After being thoroughly fed-up with the state of WordPress comment spam protection, I have decided to solve the comment spam problem in WordPress blogs once and for all. I have installed an experimental commenting system which is designed to completely stop (read 100%) robotic spam (spam generated by bots and not humans) in all my blogs and with no (read 0%) false positives.
Recipe for a comment spam free site for WordPress UsersDecember 24th, 2004 My recipe for getting rid of comment spam once and for all:
Install WordPress 1.2.1 or later. Install ImageAuth hack
Go to Options Tab.
The Death of Akismet (WordPress Spam Prevention Plugin)?May 28th, 2006 Akismet is a spam prevention plugin from the WordPress author, Matt Mullenweg. It uses collective wisdom in filtering spams.
Comment Guard Pro (WordPress Comment Spam Protection Plugin) Released for Internal TestingNovember 30th, 2007 I like to say that Comment Guard Pro will be the final plugin you will ever need for WordPress comment spam protection. It contains 18 pluglets for protecting you from comment spam, an open API for you to write your own pluglets, detailed live statistics (AJAX updated) and more.
Comment Guard Pro: Over 1 Million Comment Spam BlockedDecember 20th, 2007 Ever since we installed Comment Guard Pro, anti comment-spam plugin on this blog, it stopped over 1 millon spam comments (1001011 spam comments were blocked by Angsuman's Comment Guard plugin in 335 days 8 hours 38 minutes. 99.338 % of the comments received during this time were spam.) so far (look in the right sidebar for latest stats).
Abusing Comment Name field for SEO.. No SirSeptember 9th, 2007 Sometimes I see comments where the name of the person is not really his name but a popular keyword which obviously links to his website. While I understand the need to have link-love for useful comments and even encourage it, the name field shouldn't be abused by using keywords like "Web Banner Design", for example.
Meta-Review of WordPress Matt's Automattic(sic) Spam StopperOctober 31st, 2005 Matt, author of WordPress blogging software, has released an anti-spam plugin for WordPress - Automattic Spam Stopper (now renamed as AKismet)
Bad Behavior, a competing rather effective comment spam prevention plugin, author nicknamed IOError posted a review which points out some obvious downsides of such centralized spam filtering mechanisms like:
1. Privacy concern - all your comments are send to Matt's server for human inspection
2.
Spamming By "Email This Article" FeatureNovember 27th, 2006 In Simple Thoughts blog and many other blogs worldwide there is a feature to email an article you liked (or hated) to your friends. Recently I noticed that this feature is being abused to send SPAM.
How To Fix phpBB Error - The submitted form was invalid. Try submitting again.March 22nd, 2008 Users, including forum admins, sometimes gets message while editing a post, sometimes for quick edits and sometimes for longer edits - "The submitted form was invalid. Try submitting again."
This is not really an error but one of the two protection mechanisms in place in phpBB to protect your forum from spams.
Strong Anti-Email Spam Protection In Place...November 3rd, 2007 We are tweaking our postfix servers to offer maximum spam protection upfront with helo checks, header checks, blacklist checks, RBL's and more. So far my daily spam count has dropped from about 3000-7000 spams / day to about 15-35 spams per day.
Comment Guard Pro Beta 0.3 ReleasedFebruary 22nd, 2007 Comment Guard 0.3 Beta is a bug fix release. Very occassionally the plugin would request a valid commenter to submit his comment again.
December 7th, 2007 at 12:18 pm
Akismet does not prevent comments from being added to old posts. It does have an option which deletes spam comments added to posts over a month old, rather than hold them for review, which is quite nice for low-to-mid-traffic blogs as those spam comments can pile up rather quickly.
December 7th, 2007 at 2:53 pm
I agree with you. While I’ve noticed that older posts tend to be targeted by comment spammers, I’ve also received some good comments on these older posts as well.
Using a time restricted commenting plugin also dulls the value Related Posts and other similar plugins as well.
December 8th, 2007 at 7:31 am
James,
Akismet (controlled by an option)dies when a reader tries to comment on a post older than 1 month. It does it while submitting the comment.
In essence if this option is checked, Akismet assumes that the comment is a spam, guilty before any fair trial. Akismet is just an example. There are other plugins too which does this by making the post non-commentable.
Frank you have raised a very valid point. Many of us show related posts which may be from the past. When a user browses to such posts he will find that they cannot be comented upon.
December 9th, 2007 at 1:53 am
The option which you’re referring to is “Automatically discard spam comments on posts older than a month.” With this option enabled, Akismet will only automatically delete a comment left on an old post if it has been judged as spam by Akismet. Legitimate comments make it through without a problem.
December 12th, 2007 at 12:42 pm
You are right, Akismet first checks for its spamminess before. However it is well known that Akismet returns lots of false positives. In fact your comment above was marked as spam by Akismet!
While Akismet spam queue was intended for checking for such false positives, in reality with several thousands in the spam queue, it is almost impossible to check them, so effectively when Akismet marks something as a spam it becomes a spam and in case of comments on older posts they are deleted. However Akismet is just one of the many plugins which target comments on older posts. The focus of this article isn’t Akismet, which was merely mentioned en passant, but the concept of rejecting (in one form or other) or even discriminating against comments on older posts.
I contend that we cannot determine the spamminess of a comment looking merely at how old the post it has commented on.