Book Review: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince (Two Thumbs Down) �\����F�n���[�|�b�^�[�ƍ��������q�i 2�̐e�w�_�E���j
I am very disappointed.���͔��Ɏ��]�����B
The storyline especially the death looked very contrived; the death was as if publisher (or someone else) forced Mrs. Rowling to kill someone important and he was chosen.���ɁA�X�g�[���[�̎�����ɐl�דI;�̎��́A�o�ŎЂƂ��Ă̏ꍇ�i�܂��͒N���j��]�V�Ȃ�������d�v�ȃ~�Z�X���[�����O������E���Ɣނ��I�ꂽ�悤�ł��B The logic behind the sequence of events were very flimsy.���W�b�N�̔w��ɂ͔��ɔ�����ȃV�[�P���X�̃C�x���g�ł��B Also the death takes away the factor that holds together the tomes.�܂��A���ɍ��킹�č��ރg�[���Y���q���i�[����܂��B
Overall it appeared too much planning but less heart has gone into this volume.�S�̓I�߂���v�悪���Ȃ����Ƃ����̒��S�́A���̃{�����[���ł��B As if it was a desperate attempt to pensieve all the storyline together and bridge the apparent puzzles.�Ƃ���K���̎��݂Ƃ��ďꍇ�́A���ׂẴX�g�[���[��pensieve�ꏏ��u���b�W�A�������̃p�Y���ł��B
In this book you will find several characters behaving much different from their normal style and capabilities and they are not under any spell either AFAICT.���̖{�ɂ͂��Ȃ�قȂ��āA�������̕�����ʏ�̍s���X�^�C����\�͂�����Ƃ���Ă��Ȃ��C�ӂ̃X�y���̂����ꂩafaict����Ă��܂��B That really make it a painful reading at times.�ɂ݂����Ƃ�Ǐ��Ɍ��Ė{���Ɍ�ʂ����X����B
The book ended without any direction.���̖{��C�ӂ̕��ɏI�����܂��B Unlike the other books in the series it was pervading with a sense of fear all throughout.���̃V���[�Y�Ƃ͈قȂ�A���̏��Ђ�T�����Ƃ��L�܂��Ă���Ƌ��|�������ׂĂ�ʂ��Ăł��B In the previous volumes there were a lot to go on with the storyline other than Voldy factor.�́A�O�̊����ɂ͑����̃X�g�[���[�ɍs���ȊOVoldy�͈��q�ł��B This was all about Voldy, about his early life, killings and death etc. At some point Mrs. Rowling has stopped writing for children.����͂��ׂĖ�Voldy�́A�ނ̏���̐����ɂ��ẮA�E�l�Ǝ��Ȃǂ̂����ꂩ�̎��_�~�Z�X���[�����O���q�������̎��M���~���܂��B Frankly I am at a loss as to the target audience.�����Ɏ��͓r��ɕ��Ď����҂��^�[�Q�b�g�ɂ��܂��B My overall impression was that little inconsequential events were thrown in simply as an interlude.���̑S�̓I�Ȉ�ۂ͎��ɑ���Ȃ����Ƃ͂Ȃ��ƁA�P�ɃC�x���g�Ƃ��Ċԑt���X���[����܂��B If I were to name it I would name the tome as - Tribute to Voldy������������ɖ��O�����̖��O�̓g���Ƃ���-V oldy�̓g���r���[�g
In conclusion I must say that if you haven't bought it yet, don't bother.���_�I�ł���ƌ��킴��Ȃ����Ƃɑ��郌�r���[�͂܂������Ă��Ȃ��ꍇ�́A�킴�킴�ł��B It's a waste of time and money.����͎��ԂƂ����̖��ʌ����ł��B Go outside and bask in the sun with a picnic basket instead.�s���O�œ��ڂ������������ɁA�s�N�j�b�N�p�o�X�P�b�g�ł��B
I think I know what will happen in the final volume and how Voldy will die.���ɉ����N���邩�Ǝv���m���Ă̍Ō�̃{�����[���Ƃ͂ǂ̂悤Voldy�͎��ʁB Half Blood Prince will spring yet another surprise at the end of volume eight completing the final piece of puzzle.�v�����X�́A�ʂ̌��t�̔����͂܂�����܂���t���̏I���ɋ����̍Ō�̍�i��8�̃p�Y�����������܂��B
Oh one parting thought for Mrs. Rowling.����1�̕ʂ�̍l�������[�����O�~�Z�X�ł��B Please don't write detective stories.�T�㏬���̏������݂͂��������������B It's not your style.����͂��Ȃ��̃X�^�C���ł��B
PS. ps�̂ł��B And don't even get me started on the strange logic (if there is one after all) of horcruxes and why it was just not simpler to kill the main-Voldy first instead of his bottled away parts later on at leisure.�ł͂Ȃ��ɂ���ȃ��W�b�N������Ă��ĊJ�n���ꂽ�i��ɂ��ׂĂ̏ꍇ�ɂ�1�j��horcruxes�Ɨ��R���E�����Ƃ͊ȒP����Ȃ��ƍŏ��̂ł͂Ȃ��A���C��- Voldy�͔ނ̕r�l��away���i�ւ̃��W���[�ɂ��܂��B And the incessant arguments between Harry with his Scooby gang, who for some strange reason has suddenly lost faith in Harry, is boring to say the least.�n���[�|�b�^�[�Ɣނ̊ԂŐ₦�ԂȂ���scooby�M�����O�A who���R�͂������̊�ȐM��ˑR����ꂽ�n���[�́A�T���߂Ɍ����Ă��ދ�ł��B Oh yeah there are some predictable romances with tons of "snogging".����Ⴀ�����g���ɂ́A��������\���\�ȗ�������" snogging "�ł��B At least I learnt a british slang.���Ȃ��Ƃ����w�щp���̑���ł��B
Filed under��o����� Headline News�j���[�X�̌��o�� , �A Life���� | |
| |
RSS 2.0 RSS 2.0�� | |
Trackback�g���b�N�o�b�N this Article |���̋L��|
Email this Article�d�q���[�����̋L��
You may also like to read��ǂނ悤�ɂ��邱�Ƃ��\ |




































July 30th, 2005 at 11:28 pm 2005�N7��30��11:28 pm��
I�fm also quite disappointed with the story.�������ɗ��_���ĕ���ł��B It deviates from the previous style.����ȑO�̃X�^�C�����瘨�����܂��B
November 2nd, 2005 at 10:30 am 2005�N11��2��ߑO10����
here u can read Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince :������u���ǂ߂�n���[�|�b�^�[�ƍ������v�����X�F http://
[[URL Edited because a. [ [ URL��ҏW�������߁A a. I do not condone the illegal activity and b.���͑�ڂɁA��@�s�ׂ�B The site doesn't exist yet]]���̃T�C�g�����݂��Ȃ��ꍇ�͂܂�����܂���] ]