Giving babies Tylenol may blunt vaccines’ effects
Giving babies Tylenol to prevent fever when they get childhood vaccinations may backfire and make the shots a little less effective, surprising new research suggests.
It is the first major study to tie reduced immunity to the use of fever-lowering medicines. Although the effect was small and the vast majority of kids still got enough protection from vaccines, the results make “a compelling case” against routinely giving Tylenol right after vaccination, say doctors from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
They wrote an editorial accompanying the study, published in Friday’s issue of the British medical journal, Lancet.
The study only looked at preventive use of Tylenol — not whether it is OK to use after a fever develops.
Tylenol or its generic twin, acetaminophen, is widely recommended as a painkiller for babies. Many parents give it right before or after a shot to prevent fever and fussiness, and some doctors recommend this. The CDC’s vaccine advisory panel says it is a reasonable thing to do for children at high risk of seizures, which can be triggered by fevers.
However, fever after a vaccine isn’t necessarily bad — it’s a natural part of the body’s response. Curbing fever, especially the first time a baby gets a vaccine, also seems to curb the immune response and the amount of protective antibodies that are made, the new study found.
It was led by military and government scientists in the Czech Republic and was done at 10 medical centers in that Eastern European country. It involved 459 healthy infants, 9 to 16 weeks old, who were getting vaccines against polio, pneumonia, meningitis, whooping cough, tetanus, hepatitis and other childhood diseases.
Half were given three doses of Calpol, or paracetamol — a Tylenol-like brand sold in Europe — during the first day after vaccination. The others were given nothing besides the vaccines.
Babies given the painkiller were significantly less likely to develop a fever — 42 percent versus 66 percent of the others — and very few in either group developed a high one.
However, lower rates of protective antibody levels from several vaccines were seen in the group given the drug. Levels remained significantly lower in this group after booster vaccines, given when the babies were 12 to 15 months old.
Next, the researchers looked at 10 other vaccine studies and found some supporting evidence that using Tylenol to prevent fevers at the time of vaccination may curb immune system response rates. The same may not be true of using the drug to treat fevers after they develop.
The research was sponsored by Belgium-based GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, which makes all the vaccines used in the study. Some authors have financial ties to the company, including owning stock in it, and Glaxo had a role in reporting the results.
Even with the fever-lowering drugs, more than 90 percent of children in the Czech study achieved protection from the various vaccines after the booster dose, so the effect of lower levels of antibodies on any individual might be small, Dr. Robert Chen and two other CDC doctors wrote in an editorial.
Yet the consistency of findings from other studies makes “a compelling case against” routine use of fever-lowering medicines during immunization, they write.
It’s not known if Tylenol or other painkillers might reduce vaccine response in adults, but they are less likely to develop a fever after vaccination or to be so bothered by it, said Dr. John Treanor, a vaccine specialist at the University of Rochester Medical Center in Rochester, N.Y., who had no role in the study.
Tylenol is the only member of the family of over-the-counter pain relievers that is not a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug, or NSAID.
“There’s been speculation for a long time that the use of NSAIDs might have an effect” on antibody production after vaccination, but this is far from proved, Treanor said.
Given that so few children develop high fevers after vaccines, skipping the meds unless fever develops “may be the way to go,” he said.
On the Net:
Lancet: www.lancet.com
Related News
Coffee can give kids 'sleepless nights, breathing problems'October 9th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Giving coffee to babies won't keep them awake as in case of adults, in fact the hot beverage would have a long-lasting and detrimental effect on little ones' sleep and breathing patterns in adulthood, says a new study. Breathing problems are the leading causes of hospitalisation and death in premature babies.
1 million premature babies worldwide die every yearOctober 5th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Over one million infants who are born too early die each year, according to a new White Paper. Titled 'The Global and Regional Toll of Preterm Birth', it shows that in 2005, an estimated 13 million babies worldwide were born preterm - defined as birth at less than 37 full weeks of gestation - which was almost 10 percent of total births worldwide.
Childhood cancer survivors' children not at increased disease riskOctober 2nd, 2009 WASHINGTON - People who have survived cancer as a child can now have a sigh of relief, for two new studies have found fewer risks of their childhood disease on their babies. While it is believed that fertility can be compromised by cancer treatment, the studies led by researchers at Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center observed few risks to babies born to parents who underwent cancer treatment in childhood or adolescence.
Cooling therapy 'cuts infant brain damage risk'October 1st, 2009 LONDON - Brain damage caused by lack of oxygen at birth can be averted by applying a hi-tech version of an ice pack to the head, major research suggests. Cooling the brains of newborn babies deprived of oxygen dramatically improves the proportion who survive unharmed, two decades of research has shown.
How to make flu shots easier for kidsSeptember 27th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Kids often cry or scream when they are about to get an injection. Now, experts from Mattel Children's Hospital UCLA have offered certain tips to minimize the pain associated with the needlestick.
J&J recalls 21 types of infants', children's liquid Tylenol because of potential bacteriaSeptember 24th, 2009 J&J recalls infants', children's liquid TylenolNEW YORK — Johnson & Johnson's McNeil unit is voluntarily recalling 57 lots of infants' and children's liquid Tylenol products because of possible bacterial contamination. The products being recalled were made between April and June and include nearly two dozen varieties, including Children's Tylenol Suspension 4 oz.
Johnson & Johnson recalls lots of infants', children's Tylenol because of potential bacteriaSeptember 24th, 2009 J&J recalls lots of infants', children's TylenolNEW YORK — Johnson & Johnson's McNeil unit said Thursday it is voluntarily recalling 57 lots of infants' and children's liquid Tylenol products because of possible bacterial contamination. The products being recalled were made between April and June and include nearly two dozen varieties, including Children's Tylenol Suspension 4 oz.
Basic hygiene 'more effective against swine flu than drugs'September 23rd, 2009 LONDON - A new study has found that maintaining basic hygiene like washing hands and using face masks can control the spread of swine flu more effectively than vaccines and antiviral drugs. The report has been published in the British Medical Journal.
Drugmaker Merck, British research charity to develop vaccines for diseases in poor countriesSeptember 17th, 2009 Merck, British charity to jointly develop vaccinesTRENTON, N.J. — Drugmaker Merck & Co.
Novel 'adjuvant' may help develop new vaccinesSeptember 15th, 2009 WASHINGTON - In a novel study, Oregon State University scientists have developed a new "adjuvant" that would allow the creation of important new vaccines for various diseases. It can possibly become a universal vaccine carrier, and help medical experts tackle many diseases more effectively.
Estrogen supplements may not prevent bone loss in postmenopausal womenSeptember 3rd, 2009 WASHINGTON - Dietary supplements that claim to have the power of estrogen and help postmenopausal women with bone health may not be as effective as previously believed, says a new study. Women who are menopausal or postmenopausal produce less estrogen, that leads to bone loss.
Vitamin C deficiency may impair newborn babies' mental developmentSeptember 3rd, 2009 WASHINGTON - A new study has revealed that vitamin C deficiency may impair the mental development of newborn babies. The study showed that guinea pigs, which lack vitamin C, have 30 per cent less hippocampal neurones and significantly worse spatial memory.
China set to approve swine flu vaccines requiring only 1 doseSeptember 2nd, 2009 China set to approve 1-dose swine flu vaccinesBEIJING — China will soon approve domestically developed swine flu vaccines that manufacturers say can protect people against the virus with only one dose, an encouraging development for health officials racing to prepare for an expected spike in cases this winter. Many health authorities are assuming two doses of vaccine are necessary while they await the results of trials by drug makers around the world to determine the appropriate dosage.
CVS will make flu shots available at clinics and drug stores on Sept. 1, several weeks earlyAugust 31st, 2009 CVS will start giving seasonal flu shots TuesdayNEW YORK — CVS Caremark says it is making flu shots available starting Tuesday, which is three or four weeks earlier than usual. The company said the vaccine will be available throughout the fall at all 500 of its walk-in MinuteClinics, and at scheduled events in many of its 6,900 drugstores.
CVS and Walgreen to start giving flu shots Tuesday, programs start earlier this yearAugust 31st, 2009 Drugstores to start giving flu shots TuesdayNEW YORK — Drugstore operators are beginning their seasonal flu shot campaigns several weeks early this year, saying they expect greater demand for the vaccine in a year when the swine flu strain has dominated the news. CVS Caremark Corp.
