In Jackson case, what constitutes manslaughter?
LOS ANGELES — If Michael Jackson’s death turns into a manslaughter case, prosecutors would have to show that his doctor acted in a negligent or reckless fashion in causing the pop star’s death.
The possibility of such a charge emerged Wednesday after authorities served a search warrant at the Houston offices of Dr. Conrad Murray, Jackson’s personal physician. Murray’s attorney, Ed Chernoff, said investigators were looking for items “they believed constituted evidence of the offense of manslaughter.”
Such a charge does not require an intent to kill and experts said the focus would more likely be on whether Murray took unnecessary risks in administering a drug or drugs to Jackson.
To prove a charge of manslaughter, authorities must show there was a reckless action that created a risk of death or great bodily injury. If a doctor is aware of the risk, there might also be an issue of whether the patient knows that risk and decided to take it.
A patient’s complicity in taking the risk could reduce the doctor’s culpability, said Harland Braun, a prominent Los Angeles defense attorney who has represented doctors in cases involving administering of drugs.
“Every drug has a risk,” he said. “In the case of a manslaughter charge, you have to show it was a reckless risk to even administer it and that the drug was administered in a reckless manner.”
The search warrants for Murray’s office were obtained by the Los Angeles Police Department. LAPD detectives were joined in the search by agents from the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration.
DEA spokeswoman Violet Szeleczky said the search was focused on records, not drugs.
Chernoff said agents left with “a forensic image” of a computer hard drive and 21 documents.
Braun said the seizure of a computer indicates authorities are looking not just for patient records but also for e-mails either between the doctor and Jackson or orders for prescription drugs.
Loyola University law professor and former federal prosecutor Laurie Levenson said a search warrant gives authorities the opportunity to talk to employees at Murray’s office. She said they may be seeking evidence of a cover-up or use of pseudonyms in providing Jackson with drugs.
Murray, a cardiologist, was hired by Jackson not long before the pop star’s death on June 25. The doctor was with him in Jackson’s rented mansion and tried to revive him when he was found unconscious.
Among the drugs found in Jackson’s home was the powerful anesthetic propofol, according to a person with knowledge of the investigation. The person is not authorized to speak publicly and requested anonymity.
Propofol depresses breathing and the heart rate and lowers blood pressure so it’s supposed to be administered by an anesthesia professional in a medical setting.
Braun said doctors are permitted to administer a drug for uses not specified on the drug label as long as they don’t use it in a reckless manner. But the responsibility for the use falls on the doctor.
Related News
Joe Jackson says 'someone should pay' for son Michael Jackson's deathAugust 31st, 2009 Joe Jackson: 'Someone should pay' for son's deathNEW YORK — Michael Jackson's father says he'd never heard of the drug propofol until it was implicated in his son's death. "I'm not angry.
Coroner rules Michael Jackson death a homicide, sedatives primary causeAugust 28th, 2009 Coroner rules Michael Jackson death a homicideLOS ANGELES — The Los Angeles County coroner says Michael Jackson's death was a homicide primarily caused by two drugs. In a statement released Friday, the coroner said the cause of death was acute intoxication from the anesthetic propofol.
MJ pleaded for drugs from his doctor, shows affidavitAugust 26th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Even though late King of Pop Michael Jackson's death has been ruled as a homicide by the L.A. County coroner, an affidavit has revealed new details about actions of the singer's doctor.
Don't blame Dr. Murray for Jackson's death, says MJ's biographerAugust 24th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Michael Jackson's personal doctor should not be held responsible for the singer's death - because he was just trying to help, says the King of Pop's former friend and biographer J. Randy Taraborrelli.
J's personal doc 'to be charged with manslaughter'August 20th, 2009 LONDON - Michael Jackson's personal physician, who allegedly administered strong anaesthetic to the star before his death, will be charged with manslaughter, according to recent reports. Dr Conrad Murray, who apparently admitted giving the sedative Propofol via an IV drip to help the singer sleep, will purportedly be taken into custody within two weeks.
MJ's mum may sue his doc for $100m over 'wrongful death'August 19th, 2009 LONDON - Michael Jackson's mother plans to sue the star's personal doctor with a 100-million dollar "wrongful death" claim. Katherine Jackson aims to target Dr Conrad Murray who admitted administering the sedative Propofol via an IV drip to help the King of Pop sleep.
JACKSON INVESTIGATORS RAID VEGAS PHARMACYAugust 11th, 2009 Authorities investigating the death of MICHAEL JACKSON have raided a pharmacy in Las Vegas in search of documents relating to drug prescriptions written by the King of Pop's personal physician DR. CONRAD MURRAY.
MJ had lethal amount of anaesthetic in system, says leaked autopsy reportAugust 8th, 2009 WASHINGTON - A lethal amount of powerful anaesthetic Propofol was found inside late King of Pop Michael Jackson's body after his death, according to leaked autopsy results. Michael died after suffering a cardiac arrest at his home in Los Angeles on June 25.
LEAKED JACKSON AUTOPSY DETAILS PINPOINT PROPOFOL AS CAUSE OF DEATHAugust 7th, 2009 MICHAEL JACKSON had a lethal amount of powerful anaesthetic Propofol in his system when he died, according to leaked autopsy results. The Thriller hitmaker suffered a fatal cardiac arrest at his Los Angeles home on 25 June (09).
KATHERINE JACKSON NOT CONVINCED OF MICHAEL'S NATURAL DEATHAugust 3rd, 2009 MICHAEL JACKSON's mother refuses to believe her son's tragic death was the result of natural causes, insisting he was "too young" to pass away so suddenly. The Thriller hitmaker died on 25 June (09) at the age of 50 after suffering a cardiac arrest.
MJ 'labelled drug addict' in police warrantsAugust 1st, 2009 MELBOURNE - Michael Jackson has reportedly been labelled a drug addict in search warrants lodged with the Nevada District Court. Police investigating Jackson's death were said to have seized the contents of seven computer drives and three telephones from the home and office of the star's personal physician Dr Conrad Murray.
Federal agents search Las Vegas home of Michael Jackson's doctor in manslaughter probeJuly 28th, 2009 Federal agents search home of Jackson's doctorLAS VEGAS — Federal authorities are searching the Las Vegas home of Michael Jackson's personal doctor. Officials with the Drug Enforcement Administration were at Dr.
Cops probing MJ's death hunting for his doctor's assistantJuly 27th, 2009 LONDON - Cops probing late Michael Jackson's mysterious death have stepped up the hunt for Dr. Conard Murray's assistant.
MJ's death probe: Cops seek 'kill' cluesJuly 25th, 2009 LONDON - Officials investigating the death of Michael Jackson were on the lookout for evidence that the star was murdered by his personal doctor when they searched the medic's clinic. Officials were given a search warrant, indicating that Jackson's doctor, Conrad Murray, was the target of a manslaughter probe into the singer's death.
Michael Jackson's Death Certificate CopyJuly 8th, 2009 LONDON - We have got a copy of Michael Jackson's death certificate that has emerged online, stating the cause of death as "deferred". The document apparently lists "entertainment" as the type of business, and his occupation as a "musician".