Film: “Detective Naani”; Director: Romilla Mukherjee; Cast: Ava Mukherjee, Zain Khan, Simran Singh, Shweta Gulati, Amit Varma, Amrita Saluja, Ankur Nayyar and Hemu Adhikarie; Rating: **
As the title suggests, “Detective Naani” is a simple story about a granny (Ava Mukherjee) who has those intrinsic detective traits to her. She may not be trained like the CID officers she comes in contact with as the story progresses, and nor is she expected to be physically agile like youngsters.
Still, this 75-year-old lady has decades of experience behind her and a ’strong instinct’ factor that makes her see things that others may ignore.
This is where the film’s basic plot comes into the picture as ‘naani’ suspects something fishy going on in her neighbourhood. She has a strong reason to believe that children in her locality are going missing. But no one wants to believe her. Her approaching the cops too proves to be futile and it is left entirely to her to get her own team - a bunch of youngsters, her grandchildren and a few other friendly neighbourhood folks - together and solve the mystery.
But this journey to the bottom takes its own time and it does become a little tiring intermittently. All you want to know is the ‘what’, ‘who’, ‘where’ and ‘why’ behind the mysterious happenings but filmmaker Romilla Mukherjee brings in other Bollywood masala elements to overtly dramatise the affair.
However, as is a mandatory requirement of any suspense flick, the end should keep you interested in the proceedings and this is what happens in case of “Detective Naani” as well. After a good beginning and an average middle portion, the last few reels manage to pull back the movie, saving it from being an entirely lame exercise.
What impresses most about the movie are the tricks that ‘naani’ applies to find the culprits. The clues that she detects to move a step ahead may not be the kind that one finds in the theory book, but they have a practical touch to them.
From the performance standpoint, the film was meant to be the ‘naani’ affair all the way and Ava Mukherjee doesn’t disappoint. Though a known face on the commercial circuit, she has been doing films only sparsely - she was earlier seen in “Darna Zaroori Hai” and “Devdas”. “Detective Naani” is the first time that she has been seen as a protagonist in a Bollywood flick.
Ankur Nayyar as the CID officer does quite well too though he comes with the disadvantage of appearing in a film where he primarily has a supporting role.
The film’s music is boring, though the background score is reasonably good.
It’s easy to dismiss a film based on just the title, genre and the star cast. The same applies to “Detective Naani”, which arrives sans any promotion, has unknown faces and isn’t quite forthcoming of its genre - is it comedy, a family film or a thriller?
But if one keeps all these aside and focuses just on the story and its execution, it’s not a bad watch at all. “Detective Naani”, which has first-timer Romilla Mukherjee taking up the multiple responsibilities of a producer, director, lyricist, composer and screenplay writer, isn’t the summer kiddie flick that you were waiting for.
Still, if you have absolutely nothing else to watch and are through with your daily dose of IPL, “Detective Naani” is all right for lazy weekend viewing.
Related News
'Sherlock Holmes' sequel in pipeline?September 22nd, 2009 LONDON - Hollywood movie bosses are reportedly planning a second Sherlock Holmes film even before the first instalment has hit the big screen. The film's trailer has received mixed reviews by critics but movie chiefs are rounding up writers to draft a script for a follow-up to the Arthur Conan Doyle tale, according to the Hollywood Reporter.
'Up' an animation with lots of action and emotion (IANS Film Review - Rating: ****)September 20th, 2009 Film: "Up"; Voices: Edward Asner, Christopher Plummer, Jordan Nagai, Bob Peterson; Director: Pete Docter; Rating: ****
Now this is turning out to be too bad to be true. Just like "District 9" last week, even "Up" has arrived at Indian shores sans any fanfare.
'Ruslaan': Tacky film on a serious issue (IANS Film Review; Rating: *)September 12th, 2009 Film: "Ruslaan"; Cast: Rajveer Sharma, Megha Chatterjee, Smita Jaykar, S.M. Zaheer, Shahbaaz Khan, Ganesh Yadav, Asrani; Director: Mohan Sharma; Rating: *
The audience can't really be blamed if they make up their minds weeks before the release of the film based on its promos.
I'm a blessed actor: Rishi Kapoor (Film Snippets)September 1st, 2009 NEW DELHI - From his first film "Bobby" (1973) till now - Rishi Kapoor had a smooth journey in Hindi films and admits that he has been a blessed actor as compared to many others. "I'm very satisfied with my career graph.
DTS mixing stage for GundragoviAugust 20th, 2009 Producer TN Gopala Krishna and Mahesh’s Gundragovi is now in its DTS mixing stage. Starring Sathya (of Aa Dinagalu and Slum Bala fame), the film is set in a rural backdrop and is about an illiterate and lazy guy who has a special character.
126 Days of JoshAugust 19th, 2009 The 126 days celebration of the film Josh was held at The Bell Hotel recently. The event was held on Friday evening and KCN Chandrasekhar, TS Nagabharana, Nagathihalli Chandrasekhar, Pal Chandani etc.
'Eddelu Manjunatha': neat satirical entertainer (Kannada Film Review)July 18th, 2009 Film: "Eddelu Manjunatha"; Cast: Jaggesh, Yagna Shetty, Tabala Naani, V. Manohar, Shyam Prasad, A.S.
Keanu Reeves eagerly awaits movie reviewsJuly 3rd, 2009 LONDON - Hollywood actor Keanu Reeves can't wait to see what the critics make of his new movie because he loves finding out how his performances are rated. The Speed actor stars in new drama The Private Lives of Pippa Lee and he's awaiting the press reviews with bated breath to see if he has done a good job, reports contactmusic.com.
Lets Dance compared to Jaane Tu, Slumdog and Rock OnJune 25th, 2009 After a slow start, petite debutante Gayatri Patel’s film ‘Let’s Dance’ has picked pace, mostly with good reviews and strong word-of-mouth publicity. ‘Let’s Dance’ has “the understated romance of ‘Jaane Tu… Ya Jaane Na’, the fleeting emotions of ‘Slumdog Millionaire and the mood of ‘Rock On’,” states film reviewer Martin D’Souza in Glamsham.com.
Detective Naani: ReviewMay 22nd, 2009 Detective Naani: Grand Mess
Rating: 1.5 out of 5*
Starring: Ava Mukherjee, Master Zain Khan, Ankur Nayyar, Amrita Saluja, Shubhangi Gokhale, Amit Verma and Shweta Gulati
Director: Romilla Mukherjee
During her daily ritual of morning walk, 75 year old Naani (Ava Mukherjee the famous Dabur model) witnesses a small girl (Saili Shettye) peeping at her nervously. Intrigued, as Naani tries to find more about the girl she stumbles on a huge racket.
Can Aishwarya or Naani bring smiles to Bollywood?May 21st, 2009 Ok, so now it is turning out to be too bad to be true. All eyes were set on the Monday gone by as there was a wide spread belief that the meeting held on this day between producers and multiplexes would result in a positive outcome.
Out with Daadi, in with Naani -Ava Mukherjee May 14th, 2009 84-year-old Ava Mukherjee may have won hearts as the Ayurvedic Concepts Dadima, but people still stop her on the streets to ask her how Shahrukh is doing. Why? Because thanks to re-runs of “Devdas” on TV, they see her as Dev’s beloved Dadima again and again.
DIRECTING DETECTIVE NAANI-Romilla Mukherjee May 14th, 2009 Debutant director Romilla Mukherjee has always had a special fondness for murder mysteries and family fare. “Parinda” and “Parichay” may seem worlds apart, but she’s always believed that widely different themes can be blended beautifully together into one single movie.
Make way for the Chillar Party May 7th, 2009 UTV’s niche film sub-brand, UTV Spotboy’s latest film Chillar Party commenced shooting from Sunday May 3rd. The film marks the directorial debut of UTV Spotboy chief creative officer Vikas Bahl and Nitesh Tiwari.
Amisha Patel to enter SandalwoodMay 3rd, 2009 Rumours are going around that Bollywood beauty Amisha Patel would be entering into the world of Sandalwood with the remake of Telugu hit flick Athanokkade. Debutant Naveen will direct the film and the hero will be a newcomer.